7 Best 4 Slice Toasters To Buy

The 7 Best 4-Slice Toasters for Your Family and Kitchen 

Are you and your family toast lovers? Do you enjoy toast every morning? Or what about for lunchtime, snack time, and dinner time?

If you have a big family, this might bring chaos!

Some can enjoy their toast right away while others have to sit and wait. Your 2-slice compact toaster takes way too long to make enough for everyone. You can’t just make two slices of bread at a time!

The good news is that there a four-slice toaster can quicken the process! In a few minutes, everyone can have their warm, buttery toast. 

There are a lot of great kitchen appliances out there.

So which is the best 4-slice toaster for you? Which one should you spend your hard-earned money n?

In this article, we’re going to review our top picks for the best four-slice toasters on the market. We’ll also help you determine the best one for you by giving you a list of what to look for. So let’s get straight to it!

How to Find the Best 4-Slice Toaster for You – the 6 Things You Should Consider Before Buying

The truth is, the toaster that’s best for you will depend on your needs and preferences.

It’s important to know this before you buy any toaster or any kitchen appliance in general.

These 6 things to consider will help you determine that when looking for a toaster. 

What are the 6 things to consider? Slot dimensions, lift and lower mechanism, shade selection, modes, size, and quality and design. 

Let’s take a look at each in detail. 

Slot Dimensions

It happens more often than not. People rush to buy a toaster only to find their preferred bread toast can’t fit inside the slots. So they go and buy another toaster and another until they find one that fits the type of bread they want toasted. 

To avoid this, you need to look into the slot dimensions. You also need to answer one important question. 

What types of bread are you planning on toasting? Will you toast bagels? A Regular slice of bread? A large slice of sourdough bread? English Muffins? I think you get the picture.

Once you answer this question, it’ll be a lot easier to know what slot dimensions you need. 

For regular pieces of bread or English muffins, all the toasters’ slots can fit it, so that’s not a problem. But for the bigger or thicker bread, you need to find a four-slice long slot toaster.

Lift and Lower Mechanism 

Once the bread is toasted to your likeness, how are you planning on removing it? This is especially difficult if the bread slices are small. 

Well, this is where the lift and lower mechanism comes in. The mechanism, or lever, allows you to place the bread all the way down to toast every side evenly. And all the way up when it’s finished for easy removal. 

Obviously, a high lift lever is better so you don’t burn your fingertips taking out your slices of toast.

Now, there are two types that you can choose from – automatic or manual.

If you’re planning on multitasking, cooking eggs, or preparing to go out, the automatic is a better option. The bread will pop up once it’s finished. There’s also sometimes a bell ding to tell you when that happens. 

The manual requires you to lift the lever to pop up the toast. It’s a better choice if you want to check on the doneness or have more control over the toasting. 

There’s also another kind that has a hybrid setting called the lift and look. It allows you to quickly take a peek at your bread while it’s still toasting.

Shade Selection

Do you like your toast golden-brown? Or do you prefer it dark and crispy? Or what about a very light toast with a slight crisp?

Shade selection is also known as the browning setting.

The shade settings determine the toast you want. Usually, there are just 3 options – light, medium, and dark. If you want more options, some toasters offer up to 7 or 9 shade settings! 

If you like dark toast and your children like light and your spouse likes golden-brown, a toaster with many shade selections is the right one for you. Everyone can enjoy their preferred doneness of toast. 

Modes

Are you going to use your toaster for toasting only? What if you want to toast a bagel? Or what if you want to defrost frozen waffles before toasting?

The modes are sort of like special settings. The most common modes are bagel setting, defrost setting, and a cancel button. 

The bagel setting will toast only the inner surface of the bagel and keep warm the outer surface to give you a perfect bagel. 

Defrost settings allow you to defrost frozen pancakes or waffles, of course. Once defrosted, it will start to toast it immediately. 

The cancel button is for when you want to stop the toasting before it’s even done. 

Some other toasting modes you’ll find are “reheat” and “keep warm”. 

A toaster model with different modes means you can use it for something other than toasting bread. So it’s important to consider whether you need these extra modes or not. And if you do, find the ones that you do need. 

Size

With any kitchen appliance, size is an important matter. You don’t want to buy a huge toaster if you have little kitchen counter space. You won’t be able to store it anywhere.

Even if you do have space for a big toaster, you might not want to draw too much attention to it. A small toaster is better in this case.

So whatever your situation, always make sure you’re always aware of the toaster before buying. Seeing if it can fit your kitchen space or if it sticks out like a sore thumb on your countertops. 

Quality and Design 

Finally, you should look into the toaster’s quality and design. You definitely don’t want to buy a toaster that breaks down within a few weeks, do you? Or, as we mentioned earlier, do you want a toaster that sticks out like a sore thumb? 

For the design, it really depends on your preference. If you like to match your appliances, look for one with a similar design. For many people that would mean a stainless steel toaster. Or, if you would like it to stand out, look for one with bright colors or unique designs.

For the quality, look for one that’s solid, sturdy, and reliable. The best way to know about the quality is to ask questions about it to the seller, read customer reviews, or maybe even just buy it.

All of the products reviewed here have some kind of warranty and it’s often easy to return and get a refund.  

The Top 7 Four Slice Toasters – a Review of Each Product to Get You Started With The Best Toasters

As promised, we’re going to list our top picks for the best four-slice toasters. The best toaster for you depends on your needs and preferences, but this list will help you get started on what’s available today.  

1. Most Classic: Cuisinart CPT-180PI 4-Slice Toaster

Are you looking for a classic 4-slice toaster? This Cuisinart toaster is one of the most retro-style four slot toasters out there. 

The Cuisinart features a brushed stainless steel and black painted steel compact body that gives it a timeless look. Not only that, but the material will also ensure that it’s durable and reliable. 

The Cuisinart is also BPA-free, so you don’t have to worry about the heating elements producing chemicals in your toast. 

Also, you get a great option for modes and a browning selection. As well as other great features. 

It has a bagel setting, defrost, reheat, and cancel modes. This is probably the most settings you’ll find in a 4-slice toaster model. 

For the browning selection, you’re given 6 toasting options, 1-2 means light shade, 3-4 medium shade, and 5-6 dark shade. 

The best part is that there are 2 settings of modes and shade selections. That means that you can toast 2 slices of bread to one preference while toasting another two slices of bread to another preference.

It’s essentially two two-slice toasters in one model.

The other features it comes with are LED indicator lights, a crumb tray that you can remove, and a cord wrap. These are great features for the price.

The LED indicator lights allow you to know what mode you’re on at one glance. The detachable crumb tray makes it easy to clean. And the cord wrap, found underneath, keeps the power cord out of the way when you’re not using it. 

If you get this Cuisinart toaster model, you need to break it in first. Turn it on, put it to the highest shade selection, and wait for the manufacturing coatings to burn out. 

If you do this, you don’t have to worry about any bad smell. For further instructions, this product comes with an instruction booklet. 

This Cuisinart is hands down, one of the best 4-slice toasters for the price available today.

Cuisinart 4-Slice Toaster

Slot Dimensions: Width/Length: 1½ x 5⅜ inches

Size: L: 11.15 x W: 10.65 x H: 7.5 inches

Modes: Bagel, defrost, reheat, cancel

Shade Selection: 6 toasting settings

Other Features: LED indicator light, removable tray for crumbs, cord wrap, brushed stainless steel

2. Most Quick: Barsetto 4-Slice Toaster 

No products found.

Are you always in a hurry to make breakfast for everyone? Don’t you wish your toaster could toast faster? 

Barsetto’s 4-slice toaster has one of the best and quickest heating elements on a toaster today. It’ll only take around 2 to 3 minutes to toast 4 slices. You can say goodbye to panic toasting for the whole family during your morning rush!

The reason why it’s so quick to heat up and toast bread is because of its dual side baking feature. Both sides of the slots heat up evenly for quicker results. 

Its superior heating element isn’t the only reason why it’s quick. It’s also because there are separate controls for 2 slots each. 

Here’s an example. Let’s say you’re 4 in the family. 2 prefer light toast while the other 2 prefer darker. Since you can choose a different shade for every 2 slots, you can get 2 different toast shades in one go. So everyone can have their preferred doneness in one go. 

Again, essentially its slots heat independently. This basically means that you’re getting two two-slice toasters in one appliance.

Another great thing about this toaster is that you can combine the toasting shades as well. Since there are 2 dials of 7 shades, you can combine it to 14 shades! You can go really dark and really crispy in your toasts with this feature. 

One thing you should note! It gets rather hot on the outside when turned on. Make sure you don’t touch it and keep it away from the children. 

Barsetto 4-Slice Toaster

Slot Dimensions: Width/Length: 1½ x 5⅗ inches

Size: L: 11 x W: 10.7 x H: 7.3 inches

Modes: Defrost, reheat, cancel

Shade Selection: 7 toasting settings (can combine to 14)

Other Features: LED indicator light, removable crumb tray, cord wrap

3. Most Even: CUSIBOX 4-Slice Toaster 

Of course, you want your bread toasted evenly. Who doesn’t? This is the perfect toaster for that because of its self-centering slot guides. 

There are too many toasters out there that boast extra-wide slots to fit large and long slices of bread. The downside to that is the smaller and thinner ones won’t heat up evenly. The top will always be more burnt than the bottom. 

Why is that? The slot is too wide for the thin slice. In turn, it’ll lean a bit forward and have the top nearer the heating elements. 

This toaster also boasts wide slots. But, its wide slots have a self-centering guide. The moment you push the bread down, the guide will make sure the bread is straight and centered, no matter how thin the bread slices are.

Along with the toaster, you get a cute card with pictures that show the shade colors of each shade selection. So you know exactly what shade selection 1 to 6 looks like without having to test it. You can trust that the pictures are very accurate. 

Overall, it’s a simple toaster that does its job. And, the best part is that it’s not expensive at all. However, it’s not exactly a compact toaster, so be ready for this extra-wide toaster with extra-wide slot!

CUSIBOX 4-Slice Toaster

Slot Dimensions: Width/Length: 1½ x 5⅘ inches

Size: L: 11 x W: 9 x H: 6.8 inches

Modes: Bagel, defrost, cancel

Shade Selection: 6 toasting settings

Other Features: LED indicator light, removable crumb trays, cord storage

4. Most Options: Amstetch Four Slice Toaster

How would you like even more bread options for your toaster? Yes, we’re talking about irregularly shaped bread like croissants and pain au chocolat or even bigger pieces of bread like bagels. 

You might be thinking, “how can a croissant or pain au chocolat fit inside a toaster slot?” The simple answer is that it can’t. But with this toaster’s great feature of a grill rack, you can heat these types of bread to give it a lovely warmth along with its buttery or chocolatey taste. 

The way you do this is to install the grill rack above the slots. Place the irregular-shaped bread on top of the grill rack. Turn on the toaster and put it in reheat mode. 

The steam will then rise up from the slots and heat the bread in the grill rack. You can easily heat your croissants, pain au chocolat, sandwiches, tortillas, and even pizza slices! 

While you’re doing that, you can toast bread inside. The normal toast function will still produce heat to rise up from the slots to the grill rack and heat whatever is in it. 

You might worry that its focus on the grill rack will remove a lot of its “toaster performance”. That is not true at all. It functions as a top-quality toaster still. 

What’s more, it’s a very compact toaster. You can take it with you anywhere, to your office, to a campsite, or anywhere else without any trouble. 

One nuisance that you might find annoying, though, is that the power cord sticks out from the front. You might not like the sight of that as the toaster sits on your countertops. 

Amstetch Four Slice Toaster

Slot Dimensions: Width/Length: 1½ x 5⅖ inches

Size: L: 5.88 x W: 2.75 x H: 3.54 inches

Modes: Bagel, reheat, defrost,  cancel

Shade Selection: 7 shade selection options

Other Features: LED indicator light, removable crumb trays, grill rack, High Lift Lever, good price

5. Most Lengthy: Maxi-Matic ECT-3100 4-Slice Toaster 

Don’t you wish you could fit in longer bread, like sourdough artisanal bread in your toaster? Well, with this four-slice model, that’s now possible. 

Instead of 4 vertical slots, this toaster has 2 horizontal slots reaching 10 inches long! 

In one slot, you can either toast 2 slices of bread or a long slice of sourdough. It’s still considered a 4-slice toaster but there’s a catch, which is a chance to enjoy long bread as toast. 

So although it’s technically a two slice toaster, it’s long enough to easily fit four slices.

You might worry that it’ll take up so much room on your countertops. It won’t. Still, these extra-wide slots and special settings will make this your favorite 2 slice toaster!

Did you know that this toaster model boasts to have a space-saving design? This is because, though it’s very long, it’s also very slim. 

You can place it at the back and it won’t bother you as you use the counter for preparing meals or whatnot. 

The downside to this toaster is that it doesn’t have dual controls. You only have one set of buttons for the modes… One dial for the shade selection… And another lever for the lift/lower mechanism. 

In this case, you can only choose one mode and shade selection at a time. Probably not the best choice if your family has different toast preferences. 

However, this toaster does bring someone unique to the table. Its ability to toast longer slices than any other toaster here.

Maxi-Matic ECT-3100 4-Slice Smart Toaster

Slot Dimensions: Width/Length: 1¼ x 10 inches (long slots!)

Size: L: 15 x W: 7.25 x H: 7.5 inches

Modes: Defrost, reheat, cancel

Shade Selection: 6 shade selection options

Other Features: LED indicator light, removable crumb tray, warming rack

6. Most Affordable: AICOK 4-Slice Toaster

No products found.

Are you looking for a 4-slice toaster that’s budget-friendly? AICOK offers one of the most affordable, high-quality ones. 

I love AICOK kitchen appliances. They’re popular, high quality, and never disappoint.

Since it’s cheap, you can’t expect fancy bells and whistles like on the other toasters. It does what toasters are supposed to do. So it’s all good. 

One thing that does make it stand out among the others is its wider slots. Before you get too excited, we’ll tell you it’s not that much wider. Still, adding 1 centimeter makes a big difference. 

At 1⅗ inches, you can fit your donut or frozen waffles in to reheat it after an overnight stay in the fridge. You can do that without squishing it inside the slots. 

And, there’s no need to worry about burning your fingers or arm if you accidentally touch it. Its cool touch comes from the stainless steel material and the heat dissipation grills at the sides. The stainless steel just also happens to look pretty good, too!

It’s not a compact toaster, though. If you don’t have a lot of room in your kitchen, maybe it’s not the best toaster to get. 

Still, it’s a high-quality 4-slice toaster that looks good, works well, is easy to clean, and will also crank out toast for years to come.

AICOK 4-Slice Toaster

Slot Dimensions: Width/Length: 1⅗ x 5⅖ inches

Size: L: 33.5 x W: 18.5 x H: 25.5 inches

Modes: Bagel, defrost, cancel

Shade Selection: 7 shade selection options

Other Features: LED indicator light, removable crumb tray, cord wrap, stainless steel

7. Best High-End: All-Clad TJ824D51 4-Slice Toaster

Are you looking for a toaster that’s solid, sturdy, and reliable? This toaster provides all that and more, giving you everything you need.

It has all the basic toaster modes – reheat, defrost, bagel, and cancel. It has yet another mode, the “more time” button. 

This is also the only toaster here that has digital screens. These screens are so you can see how much more added time you’d like for your toast. So you’re not just limited to the 6 shade selections. Amazing! 

And, it has self-centering guides in each slot for the perfect toast evenness. It has wide slots for many types of bread.

On top of all that, it has a very beautiful and classy design that’ll look great in your kitchen counter. 

Does the All-Clad 4-slice toaster have it all? We think so!

Of course, since it’s one of the most high-end 4-slice toasters, it won’t come cheap. It’ll cost about 2 to 3 times more than the other toasters we mentioned here. 

One question you might ask is, “is it worth the price?” We say, yes! But it’s only you who can really answer that. 

All-Clad TJ824D51 4-Slice Toaster

Slot Dimensions: Width/Length: 1½ x 5 inches

Size: L: 8.98 x W: 13.31 x H: 12.91 inches

Modes: Reheat, defrost, bagel, cancel, more time

Shade Selection: 6 shade selection options (can add more time)

Other Features: LED indicator light, removable crumb tray, easy to clean, cord storage

Conclusion

I’d like to add one honorable mention here. One of the best overall four-slice toasters today is the Breville Die-Cast Four Slice Smart Toaster. Although we didn’t do a specific review on this one yet, the stainless steel toaster Breville has a hefty price tag but boasts a high-quality appliance. It comes in a 2 slice model and in a 4 slice one. We’ll have to do a review soon!

So you now know what to look for when looking at toasters. You also know the top 7 4-slice toasters on the market today. 

With this combined knowledge, you can go out there and find the bes toaster for you and your family.