Top 10 Best Quesadilla Makers

Buying a Quesadilla Maker has never been easier!

Look at the picture above, don’t you love quesadillas?

I typically only have them at restaurants, but I’ve recently learned that it’s super easy to make them at home.

If you’re looking for an easy way to add Mexican recipes to your home menu, one thing you should consider is quesadillas. 

Quesadillas are healthy and very versatile. Your family will never get bored with them if you know how to mix up the ingredients to give them exciting new tastes every time. 

If cooking is not your forte and you can’t create a good quesadilla on the stovetop or microwave, you can always get yourself a quesadilla maker. 

A best quesadilla maker will make it fun and easy to create delicious quesadillas in the comfort of your own home.

Top 10 Best Quesadilla Makers

In this article, we’re going to review the 10 best quesadilla makers online.  These are all high-quality kitchen appliances that are easy to use, easy to clean, non-stick, and will last for years to come.

In addition to sharing these top-rated quesadilla makers with you, we’re going to give you a few buying tips that I hope will guide you into making a tasty purchase!

George Foreman Electric Quesadilla Maker

Why we LOVED the Foreman Electric Quesadilla Maker

The George Foreman Electric Quesadilla Maker makes 10-inch quesadillas on its non-stick plates. This makes it easy to remove your large quesadilla and start making a new one without having to clean it in between. 

You don’t need to worry about your ingredients falling out of your quesadillas with this Foreman. Thanks to its press-and-seal edges, all of your ingredients are kept in place for even cooking and therefore, much better results. 

This non-stick quesadilla maker also features deep dish pockets with press and seal lines. These pockets help speed up cooking time and it’s non-stick coating ensures that your melted cheese won’t fall out and won’t stick to the non-stick surfaces.

The seal lines are lines that go across your quesadillas creating the familiar triangle shapes. Since it is deep-dish, you’ll also be able to stuff a lot of ingredients into your quesadillas. 

You don’t need to worry about storage with the George Foreman. It can be stored in an upright position. This vertical storage saves you a significant amount of space in your kitchen shelves or cabinets. 

It also features indicator lights that tell you when your appliance is ready to go. The power light indicates that there is power going into the quesadilla maker, and the preheat indicator ready light turns off once it is hot enough to add in your quesadillas. 

Don’t like waiting for your food? You will have the best quesadillas in less than five minutes using this George Foreman Electric Quesadilla Maker.

Elite Cuisine EQD-118 Maxi-Matic Quesadilla Maker

Why we liked the Maxi-Matic Quesadilla Maker

When the standard 10-inches in diameter quesadillas don’t work for your big appetite anymore, it’s time to make bigger ones. 

The Elite Cuisine EQD-118 Maxi-Matic Large Quesadilla Maker is designed to provide you larger 11-inch quesadillas for a hearty snack or meal. You can stuff your quesadillas with even more of your favorite fillings. The amount of filling you can fit into this is way more than most quesadilla makers come with. After all, who doesn’t want more melted cheese oozing from their quesadillas? 

The non-stick plates inside the device ensure that you’ll get six wedges right out of the gate. You’ll never need to worry about unevenly cooking your quesadillas again. The Elite Cuisine makes it easy to use and easy to eat your favorite Mexican food snack. 

Cheese is one of the key ingredients to any quesadilla. But as we all know, cheese can get extremely messy. This is why the cooking surface is made of high-quality non-stick material. So you don’t have to worry about cheese or other pieces of food sticking inside the appliance and therefore becoming unsanitary over time. 

Not only do you get non-stick surfaces for easy cleaning, but this product also has a removable drip tray. When grease starts to build up as you cook, it slides down to the grease tray where you can easily get it and throw it away. 

Vertical storage is the new norm for small kitchen appliances. So as you may expect, the Elite Cuisine features the same. This quesadilla maker can be easily stored vertically on a shelf or in a cabinet and you will forget it’s even there.

Brentwood TS-120 Quesadilla Maker

Why we liked the Brentwood TS-120

For those of us who are not big eaters (not me, but maybe you), a 10-inch or 11-inch quesadilla might be a bit much. That’s why the Brentwood TS-120 Quesadillas Maker makes a quesadilla 8 inches wide. 

Place your 8-inch tortilla into the quesadilla maker with its non-stick plates, add in your favorite ingredients (extra cheese if you’re feeling extra hungry), top it off with another 8-inch tortilla. Then close the lid on the unit and wait a few minutes before you enjoy your deliciously hot quesadilla. 

The manufacturers of the Brentwood TS-120 Quesadilla Maker know that you can get a bit impatient at times when you’re feeling a little hungrier than normal. That’s why they packed it with a 900W power rating to ensure that you get your quesadillas as fast as possible. 

This wattage greatly reduced cooking time and allows for better heat distribution.

No more waiting around with a rumbling tummy!

When you’ve had your fill and it’s time to clean up, the TS-120 makes cleaning super easy. Like all of the best quesadilla makers, it comes with a high-quality non-stick coating, so your melted cheese doesn’t stick to the hot cooking plates. 

This particular model also has a removable drip tray where all the grease from your cooking is collected and can be easily disposed of. Without this removable drip tray, the grease will build up on the inside of your quesadilla maker and overflow, creating a huge mess on your countertop.

Betty Crocker BC-2958CR Pizza Maker

Why we liked this Betty Crocker Pizza Maker

If you want something that cooks more than just quesadillas, you’ll want to consider the Betty Crocker BC-2958CR Pizza and Quesadilla Maker. 

This has a 12 inch cooking plates that allows you to make all sorts of delicious dishes. You can cook cheese nachos, mini frittatas, quiches, croissants, giant cookies, hors d’oeuvres, s’mores pies, cinnamon buns, party mixes, omelets, as well as pizzas and, not to forget, the best quesadilla. 

The cooking possibilities are endless with the Betty Crocker BC-2958CR. With everything that it is capable of cooking, you might not need to turn on your oven anymore. 

The 12-inch flat nonstick cooking surface makes it a very versatile machine. It is made from a high-end non-stick material that lets you slide food off the heat quickly and easily with no mess. 

This results not only in perfect quesadillas from up to 12 inch tortillas, but also in thicker quesadillas.

A self-regulated thermostat that is built-in guarantees that you’ll get the perfect golden-brown crispy quesadillas every time. The indicator lights let you know when it’s the ideal time to drop in your fresh ingredients.

When you need to store the Betty Crocker Pizza and Quesadilla maker, it’s as simple as 1, 2, 3. Simply wrap the cord around its cord wrap and it stores away neatly. Without a dangling cord, it’ll save space and you don’t need to worry about your kitchen looking cluttered.

This is an appliance that is easy to use, easy to clean, and its multiple use design and non-stick surface will make you the perfect quesadillas, in addition to all of the other foods it’ll make!

Black & Decker Quesadilla Maker

Why we liked this Black&Decker Quesadilla Maker

You may be familiar with Black & Decker power tools, accessories, hardware, and home improvement products. But did you know they also make one of the best quesadilla makers? 

Black & Decker is not quite known for its cookware and kitchen appliances but they do make some durable and versatile products for the kitchen. Their 900W, 8-inch quesadilla maker is one such product. 

This quesadilla maker can make 6 evenly cooked deep-dish crispy and perfect quesadillas. Thanks to its deep-dish pockets, you can add in all your favorite ingredients generously. Add in your favorite spices, cheese, vegetables, and meat without holding back.  

Once your ingredients are packed in, close the lid and it seals everything together nicely. No need to worry about your quesadillas falling apart when it’s finished cooking. 

The bright red color on this little kitchen appliance is sure to catch some eyes. The yellow and green patterns at the top give it a cool Mexican vibe. You won’t have just another boring old kitchen appliance on your countertop with this product. 

The waiting time is reduced to just under 5 minutes when you make quesadillas with this quesadilla maker by Black & Decker. This is because of the powerful 900W heating elements built into this little easy to use kitchen gadget.

Hamilton Beach 25409 Quesadilla Maker

Why we liked this Hamilton Beach appliance

Restaurant quality cooking is something that we all want to achieve in the home kitchen without having to spend hours of our time.

With the Hamilton Beach 25409 Quesadilla Maker, you can get restaurant-quality quesadillas right in your home kitchen in just 5 minutes!

Place your favorite flour tortilla in this Hamilton Beach 25409, and add in your choice of spices, ground meat, cheese, and more cheese. Place the second flour tortilla on top of all your ingredients and close the locking lid.

The heat turns up and as soon as the green light goes on, your custom-made, home-made, mouthwatering, quesadilla is ready! As you bite into your very own delicious creation, you will thank yourself for making the decision to get the Hamilton Beach Quesadilla Maker. 

The edges of your quesadillas will be sealed with three groves going around the entire thing. This will ensure that your ingredients stay in place all throughout the cooking and even as you’re munching on your hot quesadilla. 

This quesadilla maker also comes with a locking lid. The lid lock ensures that your quesadilla is evenly cooked and that nothing overflows out of the quesadilla maker.

Not only does it ensure beautiful, even cooking, it also helps you when you need to store your quesadilla maker. Lock the lid and store it upright in your cabinet or shelf and it stays in place for a more clutter-free environment.

Not only does Hamilton Beach produce some of the best kitchen appliances on the market, in this model, but they also produce one of the best quesadilla makers you’ll find.

Santa Fe QM2R 900-Watt Quesadilla Maker

Why we liked the Santa Fe Quesadilla Maker

Have you ever dreamt about hosting your very own at-home quesadilla fiesta? That dream can come true with the Santa Fe QM2R 900-Watt Quesadilla Maker. 

Create fine, crispy, golden-brown, hot quesadillas in under 5 minutes with this versatile kitchen appliance. You don’t have to spend hours creating enough quesadillas to feed your fiesta guests. 

This best quesadilla maker can produce 6 quesadilla wedges every 5 minutes. This is possible because of its non-stick cooking surface. You’ll never need to get a damp cloth and stop to clean the nonstick surface in between cooking sets. 

Its clean operation is also thanks to the built-in drip-tray, which catches all the excess cheese and bits of other ingredients so it doesn’t get stuck in your quesadilla maker. 

You’re not limited to making quesadillas with this appliance. You can cook up a ton of different dishes on the large 12-inch non-stick cooking surface. If you run out of ideas, the package even comes with a recipe book so you’ll always have fresh new dishes for you and your family to enjoy.

Another thing great about this particular quesadilla maker is that it comes with a 1-year limited warranty. If ever anything breaks or if your quesadilla maker malfunctions within the first year of usage, you can have it checked and repaired for free. 

This is an added benefit for your peace of mind and one of the pros that we see many people list in their reviews.

El Paso 10023 Quesadilla Maker

Why we liked the El Paso Quesadilla Maker

This El Paso 10023 Quesadilla Maker is definitely a head-turner. With its glossy bright red finish and zigzag yellow patterns, this little thing will look great on your kitchen countertop. 

The unique look is completed with a cute little pepper handle and the classic El Paso pepper logo on top. 

You and your kids are sure to enjoy making quesadillas with the El Paso 10023 Quesadilla Maker. Its simple operation makes it super easy to create delicious quesadillas. 

The non-stick cooking surface and built-in drip reservoir prevent messes and make it easy to clean.

You won’t have any trouble storing this maker because of its small size and light build. It only weighs around 4.3 pounds and measures 10 inches by 9.45 inches.

Not only that, but it can also be stored upright and it comes with a cord wrap so you can wrap the cord before storage. 

If you’re not particularly savvy when it comes to making quesadillas, you don’t have to worry. Even someone with zero quesadilla making skills can create perfectly crispy and delicious quesadillas with this best quesadilla maker. 

It even comes with a booklet of recipes so you won’t run out of great recipes to use with your family.

Nostalgia EQM200 6-Wedge Electric Quesadilla Maker

Why we liked the Nostalgia Electric Quesadilla Maker

The Nostalgia EQM200 6-Wedge Electric Quesadilla Maker comes in two sizes. You can get the 8-inch version for smaller quesadillas or the 10-inch version that you can use to cook up a lot more than just quesadillas. 

One feature we love about the Nostalgia EQM200 Quesadilla Maker is its extra-filling latch. This latch lets you choose between a thin quesadilla and a thick quesadilla that’s stuffed with a lot of ingredients inside. 

Now you can go all out with your quesadilla stuffings and not worry about your quesadilla maker overflowing. 

This quesadilla maker comes with indicator lights, a preheat indicator light, and a ready-made indicator light that tells you when your quesadillas are ready to eat. This eliminates having to check on your quesadilla once in a while to make sure it isn’t getting burned.

Emeril Lagasse 63078, Pre-seasoned Cast Iron 11-inch Round Griddle

Why we liked the Emeril Lagasse Round Griddle

The best quesadilla makers we just reviewed make it really easy for anyone to create delicious quesadillas quickly and easily, however, what if you want to try making authentic quesadillas on an actual cast iron griddle? 

Well, we’ve included this Emeril Lagasse 63078, Pre-seasoned Cast Iron 11-inch Round Griddle in our list so you can try your hands on traditional quesadilla making. 

This cast iron round griddle is pre-seasoned, which means you can use it straight out of the box. 

Maybe this won’t work for everyday quesadillas, but we’re sure you’re going to enjoy trying to make quesadillas on a comal, the traditional way.

It also means that you can use it on a grill outside, when camping over a fire, or in your backyard over a fire pit. However, there are pros and cons to everything, right?

With just a little oil, you can make sure that the cooking surface is non-stick. However, although this cast iron one may give you the best taste, it won’t be as easy to clean or use as the electric ones.

Quesadilla Maker Buying Guide

There are a few things you will want to consider before purchasing a quesadilla maker for your kitchen. We’ve listed those things down here to help you better decide which quesadilla maker will be right for you. 

Size and Capacity

One of the most important things to consider is the size and capacity of the quesadilla maker.

If you’re planning to make larger quesadillas and you’re planning to use the quesadilla maker to cook other dishes, then a larger one like a 12-inch model will make more sense. 

If you have a smaller kitchen and space is a big concern to you, you should go with the more portable and easy to store quesadilla makers, like the 8 inch ones.

Materials

If you want your quesadilla maker to work for years, you should go with one that is made of high-quality materials. Anything that is made of plastic, even if it’s hardened plastic, will not last very long. 

This is because your quesadilla maker is a heating appliance. Plastic is not durable enough to withstand the heat from the heating elements for a long time. The plastic will eventually become brittle and break. 

Easy to Clean

As we all know, the best, most delicious quesadillas can be quite messy. Especially if you’re a cheese lover and you like throwing in extra cheese whenever you can. 

The grilling creates a lot of grease, which can be really tough to clean. This makes it important to get a quesadilla maker that is easy to clean. 

Make sure your quesadilla maker uses a non-stick heating surface. This non-stick surface will save you a lot of time when it needs to be cleaned. 

Many quesadilla makers also come with a drip tray that catches all the excess grease. If the drip tray is removable, make sure that you use it when you cook!

Price

The price is also a very important thing to consider. You should get a quesadilla maker that is within your budget. 

Luckily, most quesadilla makers are very affordable. Just because they are affordable doesn’t mean they are low-quality. All of the appliances listed above are very durable and have excellent performance. 

Wrapping up with the Best Quesadilla Maker

We hope this article helps you pick one of the many best quesadilla makers that will listed above. One that you will enjoy using for years to make delicious quesadillas for you and your family. 

If you purchased one that we recommended, let us know in the comments!